Philosophers, scientists (and most humans) have been trying to answer these two questions for centuries to no avail. They breed questions like - Does a thing have to have substance to be real and if so what kind of substance would that be? Is imaginary substance possible? Must real things be material, or do they simply need to have the quality of existence?
Science believes that to be considered real, a thing must be capable of being weighed, measured, and/or counted. But that leaves out a great part of what we collectively call “reality” that science refuses to acknowledge as existing. If only measurable things are real, does that mean ideas are not real? How about dreams and fantasies? Are figments of our imagination real?
Philosophers, on the other hand, believe that if a thing has properties, it is real. Because ideas are their stock in trade, their view of real is broader and includes immaterial things. Science’s dilemma is explaining why real immaterial things like information and ideas (which are packets of information) are not real. Their inability to do so decimates the view that material substance is the defining characteristic of reality.
Which of course is fine with theologians because they are of the view that the material world before us is just a tiny part of reality. They believe the spiritual world is far more real than physical reality. Historically, humans have sensed that this realm exists but do not yet understand it. This perception has been compared to the wind. We can’t see it, but we sure can feel it.
For thinkers and feelers alike, the question, “What is real?” is vitally important because people don’t like “fake.” As such, being able to know the difference between what is real and what is counterfeit saves time, effort, and possibly great stress. I believe knowing and understanding the difference is the most important question you will ever answer.
People believe all kinds of things. We constantly question which things exist or if historical events happened. That’s why Missouri is the “Show me!” state. Seeing is believing. But magic tricks belie this view. If something is within our experience, we might “buy” it. If not, we are likely to be skeptical. Doubting Thomas refused to believe his best friends.
Is the past real? Despite the idea of time travel, it cannot be shown to exist. Artifacts are time traveling informational packets linking us to something that no longer exists. The fact is, the past is now only an idea in your head. And if you live in the past, you are living in unreality. Our mind constantly edits, adapts and/or augments memories with newly acquired information. New experiences update our mind’s contents. As such, humans constantly argue about something that does not exist: We argue about what happened, who did what to whom and what it meant.
We even argue about whether the past even existed. Was the earth created in 4000 BC or is it four billion years old? Overwhelming evidence exists to show that the earth is very old. Some see it as a point of faith that Genesis must be taken literally (and believed absolutely). But because they are using flawed criteria for what is real, they can be right according to their definition of real and still be wrong.
Neither do humans agree on ideas as to the nature of right, wrong, good and/or bad, or even whether they exist. However, humanity has devised ways to determine if a thing is likely true. The most common way is to evaluate the evidence as to how things turned out. Certainly, Christ used this standard with His “good” fruit analogy. Yet, as Aesop demonstrated in his many fables, very often what is good for one is bad for another.
Gaining an understanding of what is good and what is not is the essence of wisdom. And yet most of the wise rules for life seem to have important exceptions. So, getting to “real” is not a straight line. But it is generally acknowledged by old people that taking the time to distinguish real from counterfeit (when it comes to good, bad, right and wrong) makes life go better.
That said, it is literally impossible to definitively say what is real and what isn’t, because it all depends on the definition used as to what constitutes real and what properties are included in it. I believe something is real if it has the ability to either affect (which means to impact something) and/or effect something else (which means to bring into existence). If it is real - it is causal.
Determining whether a thing is real or unreal, requires an all-inclusive umbrella category encompassing both: This is the quality of existence. Both real and unreal things exist. But unreal things exist as names for concepts indicating a real thing’s lack. Darkness (for example) is not a thing; it is the lack of a thing. It is not a real thing because it is not causal. It can be said to be causal in the sense that darkness will kill plants. But the darkness is not causing the problem, it’s the lack of a real thing – light – that is causing the plants to perish.
This illustrates why taking the time to grasp the difference between “real” and “unreal” is of value. Increasing what is real and not wasting time trying to shrink the unreal makes a lot of difference in how things go. For example, love is a real thing because it has impact. Its opposite (meanness) is the name we give to a lack of love. Being more loving is better than being less mean!
The most powerful force we possess is our ability to produce ideas. And it is vitally important that we craft ideas that have positive impact because nothing is as powerful as an idea whose time has come. And we craft our reality by the ideas we create and those we retain. Ideas motivate our bodies to act and our hearts to love. They induce our emotions and our creativity. They unleash our passion and undergird our effort to bring ideas to fruition. We are nothing without ideas.
Only conscious Beings can create them and transmit them. One category of idea transmission is termed prayer. When we pray, we’re sending one of our very own ideas to God, asking Him to change something we either don’t like or want to be better. But does prayer work?
According to Dr. Larry Dossey, who has written 13 books chronicling the scientific studies on whether prayer works. Results gleaned from over 3000 studies were so telling, he finally had to write a book entitled, Be Careful What You Pray For, warning people to use this power wisely. When we pray, we are asking God to change the course of the universe and incline it toward our wants and desires as to future outcomes.
The first studies done on prayer showed that prayer made a clear difference. But those results were dismissed because detractors rightly claimed that it was impossible to know whether people in the control group (those not being prayed for) were prayed for unbeknownst to the researchers. But this criticism was negated in subsequent studies done during animal surgeries so that this variable could be controlled. Prayer studies were even done on bacteria and how two different petri dishes reacted to the same antibiotic. It does make a difference!
But does prayer have enough power to change the past? Dossey reported a study done where a list of people chosen at random were prayed for who stayed in the hospital the previous year. Nobody in any aspect of the study knew how these people did medically. At the conclusion, their results were unsealed. The prayed-for group did much better at healing and recovering than the control group. Did these prayers change the past and improve the state of those in need?
It all depends on who you ask. The numbers themselves are indisputable. However, some criticized the study as resembling a slot machine where the right numbers sometimes appear by chance. On the other hand, if we pray to a timeless God residing in a timebound position, He hears our prayers now but has the ability to apply them whenever He deems it appropriate.
The point is, our prayers, as part of our effort to transmit information (via God) in the form of ideas, definitely impacts our reality. Overwhelming evidence exists to support the proposition that prayers are real things that have impact, regardless of time. The science of Quantum Mechanics demonstrated almost a century ago that our thoughts are a cofactor in the formation of reality at the subatomic level. They have no idea how. But science can definitely show that it does.
Bottom line: According to numerous scientific studies, if you’re not praying fervently, you are not taking full advantage of the power our Creator has bestowed upon us! When we create and hold onto ideas encoding what is ultimately real, like goodness, kindness, and love, we can expect the positive impact they offer. In essence, seek to increase the light, don’t waste time trying to shrink the darkness. Because while they both exist, only one of them is real.
By My Friend John